Product Image

Sleep Strawberry Sunset

OLLY
4.3
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
(95 ratings)
Theanine 100 mg
Melatonin 3 mg
Product Image
Score70

A transparent, balanced sleep gummy offers practical melatonin-theanine support, with token herbs and added carbohydrate as the main limits.

How scoring works
Quantity:60 Gummy(ies) • (30 servings)
Goals:
Sleep Support
Stress Relief
Brain Health

Score 70

A transparent, balanced sleep gummy offers practical melatonin-theanine support, with token herbs and added carbohydrate as the main limits.

How scoring works
$14.69($0.48 per serving)
Vitacost
$ 14.69
Walmart
$ 18.99
Report prices

Analysis

The gummy pairs moderate melatonin with a useful theanine amount for sleep timing and relaxation. Chamomile flower, passionflower aerial parts, and lemon balm aerial parts are clearly identified.

The botanical doses are modest and unlikely to drive the main effect. Added carbohydrate is part of the chewable trade-off, while full disclosure supports a cleaner safety review.

The product fits adults who want a flavored gummy with balanced core actives. Users seeking stronger botanical support or lower carbohydrate should consider another format.

Who is it for
  • Adults who prefer flavored gummies
  • People seeking moderate melatonin
Best for
  • Sleep onset
  • Chewable relaxation support

Pros

  • Useful theanine amount
  • Moderate melatonin serving
  • Botanical plant parts are identified

Cons

  • Herbal extracts are low-dose
  • Adds carbohydrate
  • Not designed for high-strength botanical support

Warnings

  • Melatonin may cause next-day drowsiness
  • Chamomile may trigger reactions in people sensitive to ragweed-family plants

Nutrient quality

77 High impact

Theanine and melatonin provide useful core support for relaxation and sleep timing. Small botanical amounts and gummy carbohydrate limit formula efficiency.

Ingredient transparency

82 Highest impact

Every listed active amount is disclosed, and no proprietary blend obscures the formula. Complete daily directions and inactive-ingredient details are not available.

Customer satisfaction

57 Moderate impact

The aggregate satisfaction measure is favorable, with response volume determining how much confidence it deserves. Comment-level evidence is absent, so recurring complaints and purpose fit cannot be verified.

Value for money

56 Moderate impact

Useful core actives partly support the moderate serving cost. Token botanicals and gummy carbohydrate keep category value only fair.

Report analysis

Goals

Sleep Onset SupportEvening Mental Calm
Sleep Support
Impact
Highest effect
A Goal FitA- Strength of SupportB CoverageB+ Formula Quality

Melatonin and L-theanine combine circadian support with mental relaxation in a clearly sleep-focused gummy. Their disclosed amounts are meaningful, while the added botanicals provide smaller supporting contributions.

The formula covers more than one sleep pathway without relying entirely on a large proprietary blend. Chamomile, passionflower, and lemon balm are modestly dosed, so they should be viewed as secondary rather than core actives.

View goal →
Stress Relief
Impact
High effect
B- Goal FitA- Strength of SupportB CoverageB+ Formula Quality

L-theanine provides direct calming support, while melatonin and low-dose herbs make the blend more useful for stress-related sleep than daytime resilience. Theanine has meaningful human evidence, whereas the sleep-focused botanicals are supported less consistently at the listed amounts.

The key actives are individually disclosed and the theanine serving is well aligned. A coherent bedtime blend covers several calming pathways, but melatonin may cause next-day drowsiness in sensitive users.

View goal →
Brain Health
Impact
High effect
C Goal FitC+ Strength of SupportD+ CoverageB+ Formula Quality

L-theanine supports relaxation, while melatonin and calming botanicals make the formula primarily sleep focused. Sleep support can help next-day function, but direct cognitive pathway coverage remains narrow.

The major actives are clearly stated and use practical amounts, though theanine purity and botanical standardization are absent. Melatonin may cause next-day drowsiness in some users, particularly when taken too late.

View goal →
Mood Support
Impact
Moderate effect
D+ Goal FitC+ Strength of SupportD CoverageB Formula Quality

L-theanine may support relaxation, but the formula is designed more for sleep than steady daytime mood. Melatonin and calming botanicals add sedative support rather than broad mood regulation.

Theanine reaches a useful amount, while the botanical extracts are small and not standardized. Melatonin can cause next-day drowsiness and may make the gummy unsuitable before driving or other alertness-dependent tasks.

View goal →
Cognitive Support
Impact
Moderate effect
D+ Goal FitC Strength of SupportD CoverageB Formula Quality

L-theanine, melatonin, and calming botanicals form a coherent sleep-support blend that may indirectly help next-day thinking through better rest. The main active amounts are clearly disclosed.

It is not designed for daytime focus or memory, and the theanine amount is only moderate. Melatonin can cause next-day drowsiness, so the gummies should not be used before driving or safety-sensitive work.

View goal →
Productivity Boost
Impact
Moderate effect
D- Goal FitC+ Strength of SupportD+ CoverageC Formula Quality

Theanine offers only a limited connection to focused productivity. The principal relevant amounts appear substantial enough to contribute in practice.

Coverage is concentrated on calm focus and stress resilience. The broader formula is designed for another purpose, so several ingredients add little direct focus support.

View goal →
Mental Focus
Impact
Moderate effect
C- Goal FitB- Strength of SupportF CoverageF Formula Quality

L-theanine offers some calm-attention support, but melatonin and calming botanicals make sleep the clear priority. The theanine amount is useful yet lower than many dedicated calm-focus servings.

The formula lacks alertness, neurotransmitter-precursor, or cognitive-energy support for daytime tasks. Melatonin can cause drowsiness or next-day grogginess, which directly conflicts with immediate mental focus.

View goal →

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per serving
Calories
15 Calorie(s)
Total Carbohydrates
3 Gram(s)
Melatonin
3 mg
L-Theanine
100 mg
Chamomile flower extract
17 mg
Passionflower aerial parts extract
17 mg
Lemon Balm aerial parts extract
16 mg
Gluten Free Adults 18–50
Report overview
Theanine · 100 mg OverallScore82
B+ Active Ingredient Quality & BioavailabilityA+ Dose, Safety & Label TransparencyD+ Value

Clearly identified L-theanine reaches a well-aligned amount for relaxation support. Melatonin and several calming botanicals make the formula more sleep-focused, although the generic theanine lacks a stated purity standard. The cost per active amount is premium but still defensible within the broader sleep blend.

View ingredientView products
Melatonin · 3 mg OverallScore56
F Active Ingredient Quality & BioavailabilityB+ Dose, Safety & Label TransparencyC Value

The 3 mg amount sits within the range most aligned with natural circadian signaling. Chewed gummy delivery may begin breaking down quickly, but it does not provide sustained release. The high serving cost is partly supported by theanine and several clearly disclosed calming botanicals.

View ingredientView products
85 Value

Sleep Well Berry Flavored

Nature's Way
4.6
★★★★★
(919 ratings)
Combining 5mg of melatonin with Ashwagandha and Magnesium at 31 cents per serving, this gummy offers a more potent and comprehensive sleep and stress-relief formula for a better price, delivering strong overall value.
Other sellers (3)
82 Value

Triple Action Sleep

Solgar
4.5
★★★★★
(50 ratings)
Delivering 10mg of melatonin with L-Theanine and a herbal blend for 39 cents per serving, this alternative provides potent sleep support with added relaxation benefits at a competitive price, offering better overall formulation value for stronger effects.
Other sellers (2)
85 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

NOW
4.8
★★★★★
(5304 ratings)
For just 3 cents per serving, this product delivers 3mg of melatonin with added Vitamin B6, providing excellent value for a basic yet effective melatonin supplement with an added synergistic vitamin.
Other sellers (4)
90 Performance

Ortho Sleep

AOR Advanced Orthomolecular Research Advanced
4.3
★★★★★
(471 ratings)
This blend offers a more holistic approach to sleep by combining a moderate 3mg of melatonin with robust doses of GABA, L-Theanine, Valerian, and 5-HTP, which provides more comprehensive and transparent support than a proprietary herbal blend.
Other sellers (2)
92 Performance

Insomnitol

Designs for Health
4.7
★★★★★
(45 ratings)
With a diverse profile of scientifically-backed sleep aids like PharmaGABA, L-Theanine, Chamomile, and Valerian, alongside melatonin, this product offers a superior and more nuanced solution for complex sleep and stress issues.
Other sellers (1)
88 Performance

Power to Sleep PM

Irwin Naturals
4.3
★★★★★
(2827 ratings)
This alternative offers a robust blend of calming and sleep-inducing herbs like Ashwagandha, Passionflower, Hops, and Valerian, combined with melatonin and L-Theanine, providing a more comprehensive and synergistic formula for sleep and stress relief.
Other sellers (2)
75 Budget

Melatonin 3 mg

Swanson
4.7
★★★★★
(40796 ratings)
At 2 cents per serving, this 3mg melatonin option is incredibly cheap, offering a basic, effective dose at a fraction of the cost, making it a much more accessible choice for budget-conscious consumers seeking only melatonin.
Other sellers (4)
80 Budget

Melatonin 3 mg

Nature Made
4.7
★★★★★
(19134 ratings)
For just 3 cents per serving, this Nature Made product provides 3mg of melatonin from a reputable brand, representing a significantly more economical option if the multi-ingredient blend and gummy format are not essential.
Other sellers (3)
80 Budget

Melatonin 3 mg Raspberry Flavor

Bluebonnet EarthSweet Chewables
4.7
★★★★★
(61 ratings)
This chewable offers a 3mg melatonin dose for 11 cents per serving with no sugar, providing a highly cost-effective and low-carb option for similar melatonin benefits.
Other sellers (2)
85 Value

Sleep Well Berry Flavored

Nature's Way
4.6
★★★★★
(919 ratings)
Combining 5mg of melatonin with Ashwagandha and Magnesium at 31 cents per serving, this gummy offers a more potent and comprehensive sleep and stress-relief formula for a better price, delivering strong overall value.
Other sellers (3)
82 Value

Triple Action Sleep

Solgar
4.5
★★★★★
(50 ratings)
Delivering 10mg of melatonin with L-Theanine and a herbal blend for 39 cents per serving, this alternative provides potent sleep support with added relaxation benefits at a competitive price, offering better overall formulation value for stronger effects.
Other sellers (2)
85 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

NOW
4.8
★★★★★
(5304 ratings)
For just 3 cents per serving, this product delivers 3mg of melatonin with added Vitamin B6, providing excellent value for a basic yet effective melatonin supplement with an added synergistic vitamin.
Other sellers (4)
90 Performance

Ortho Sleep

AOR Advanced Orthomolecular Research Advanced
4.3
★★★★★
(471 ratings)
This blend offers a more holistic approach to sleep by combining a moderate 3mg of melatonin with robust doses of GABA, L-Theanine, Valerian, and 5-HTP, which provides more comprehensive and transparent support than a proprietary herbal blend.
Other sellers (2)
92 Performance

Insomnitol

Designs for Health
4.7
★★★★★
(45 ratings)
With a diverse profile of scientifically-backed sleep aids like PharmaGABA, L-Theanine, Chamomile, and Valerian, alongside melatonin, this product offers a superior and more nuanced solution for complex sleep and stress issues.
Other sellers (1)
88 Performance

Power to Sleep PM

Irwin Naturals
4.3
★★★★★
(2827 ratings)
This alternative offers a robust blend of calming and sleep-inducing herbs like Ashwagandha, Passionflower, Hops, and Valerian, combined with melatonin and L-Theanine, providing a more comprehensive and synergistic formula for sleep and stress relief.
Other sellers (2)
Report alternatives