Product Image

Melatonin 20 mg

NutriCology

4.4
(395 ratings)
Melatonin 20 mg
Product Image
Score 35.0

An excessively high 20 mg melatonin dose that is generally unsuitable for casual use, compounded by a less competitive price point compared to similar high-dose options.

Quantity: 60 Capsule(s)Servings size: 1 Capsule(s) (60 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Stress Relief
Anti-Aging
Sleep Support

Score 35.0

An excessively high 20 mg melatonin dose that is generally unsuitable for casual use, compounded by a less competitive price point compared to similar high-dose options.

Analysis

This product contains a substantial 20 mg of melatonin per capsule. Such a high dose is generally not recommended for most individuals seeking a typical sleep aid, as it far exceeds the amount needed to induce sleep and can lead to unwanted side effects like prolonged sedation or vivid dreams. While high doses might be used for specific clinical applications or under medical supervision, it's inappropriate for general stress relief or sleep support without guidance. Furthermore, despite its high dose, the product's price per serving is not competitive when compared to other 20 mg melatonin products that offer better value.
Pros
  • May be suitable for individuals with severe sleep disturbances or specific conditions requiring high melatonin doses, under medical guidance.
Cons
  • Excessively high 20 mg melatonin dosage for general use, highly prone to causing significant morning grogginess and other side effects.
  • Less competitive price per serving compared to other high-dose melatonin products.
  • Lacks any complementary ingredients for holistic sleep or stress support.
Warnings
  • This high dosage should only be used under the strict supervision and recommendation of a healthcare professional.
  • Not recommended as a primary sleep aid for most individuals due to the high risk of adverse effects.
Report analysis
$42.59($0.70 per serving)
Pure Formulas
$ 42.59
iHerb
$ 42.59
Amazon
$ 42.59
Report prices

Effectiveness for goals

Dosage, timing & forms

Safety & interactions

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per serving
Melatonin
20 mg
Adults 18–50 Women
Report overview

Categories

Within the Melatonin collection, this product offers a very high dose, but its general unsuitability for most users due to potential side effects and its higher price point compared to other high-dose options place it near the bottom for overall appeal.

Goals

At 20 mg, the melatonin dosage aligns with some research-level quantities explored for potent antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties, which have anti-aging implications. However, this still requires careful consideration due to the significant sedative effects and potential side effects, and is not for casual self-administration.
The 20 mg dose is generally too high for effective and comfortable sleep support for the average user, often leading to over-sedation. While it will induce sleep, the trade-off in potential side effects makes it a poor choice for routine sleep assistance, despite being a pure melatonin product.
While inducing sleep can indirectly relieve stress, this exceptionally high 20 mg dose is not designed for direct stress modulation and may cause over-sedation, potentially leading to discomfort or impaired function rather than true stress relief for many.
85 Value

Melatonin 5 mg

NOW
4.7
(11948 ratings)
Offers a common and effective 5mg melatonin dose at a vastly lower price per serving (0.07 vs 0.70), providing significantly better value for most users who do not require such an extreme dose.
85 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

21st Century
4.8
(12268 ratings)
Provides a well-regarded 3mg melatonin dose at an extremely low price per serving (0.06 vs 0.70), offering excellent value for a widely effective sleep aid.
88 Value

Power to Sleep PM

Irwin Naturals
4.3
(2630 ratings)
Offers a comprehensive sleep blend for a price per serving (0.61) that is slightly lower than the original's, yet provides a much broader range of potentially beneficial ingredients for a more effective and balanced sleep experience.
80 Performance

Sleep Nighttime Powder

youtheory
4.1
(28 ratings)
Provides a comprehensive blend of amino acids and minerals (L-5-HTP, L-Theanine, L-Tryptophan, L-Glycine, Magnesium) with a much lower, more appropriate melatonin dose (0.3mg), which nutritionists often recommend over excessively high doses for general sleep support.
90 Performance

Ortho Sleep

AOR Advanced Orthomolecular Research Advanced
4.1
(129 ratings)
Offers a balanced 3mg melatonin dose combined with a robust array of synergistic herbs and amino acids (Passionflower, 5-HTP, GABA, Valerian, L-Theanine, Lemon Balm), providing a more holistic and generally safer approach to sleep than an isolated high dose.
92 Performance

Insomnitol

Designs for Health
4.6
(32 ratings)
Features a very comprehensive and transparent blend of clinically relevant ingredients like GABA, Chamomile, 5-HTP, L-Theanine, Valerian, and Passion Flower alongside 3mg melatonin, offering superior multi-pathway support for sleep, contrasting with a singular high dose.
45 Budget

Melatonin 20 mg

NaturesPlus
4.7
(1178 ratings)
Offers the same high 20mg melatonin dose at a significantly lower price per serving (0.20 vs 0.70), making it a more cost-effective option for individuals seeking this high dosage.
75 Budget

Premium Melatonin

Sterling Health
4.5
(27 ratings)
Provides a high 10mg melatonin dose (still substantial) at an incredibly low price per serving (0.03 vs 0.70), offering vastly superior value for pure melatonin content if a very high dose is desired.
35 Budget

Melatonin Gummies 20 mg Natural Blackberry Flavor

Vitamatic
4.7
(67 ratings)
Offers the same very high 20mg melatonin dose in a gummy form at a slightly lower price per serving (0.46 vs 0.70), if the gummy format is preferred.
85 Value

Melatonin 5 mg

NOW
4.7
(11948 ratings)
Offers a common and effective 5mg melatonin dose at a vastly lower price per serving (0.07 vs 0.70), providing significantly better value for most users who do not require such an extreme dose.
85 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

21st Century
4.8
(12268 ratings)
Provides a well-regarded 3mg melatonin dose at an extremely low price per serving (0.06 vs 0.70), offering excellent value for a widely effective sleep aid.
88 Value

Power to Sleep PM

Irwin Naturals
4.3
(2630 ratings)
Offers a comprehensive sleep blend for a price per serving (0.61) that is slightly lower than the original's, yet provides a much broader range of potentially beneficial ingredients for a more effective and balanced sleep experience.
80 Performance

Sleep Nighttime Powder

youtheory
4.1
(28 ratings)
Provides a comprehensive blend of amino acids and minerals (L-5-HTP, L-Theanine, L-Tryptophan, L-Glycine, Magnesium) with a much lower, more appropriate melatonin dose (0.3mg), which nutritionists often recommend over excessively high doses for general sleep support.
90 Performance

Ortho Sleep

AOR Advanced Orthomolecular Research Advanced
4.1
(129 ratings)
Offers a balanced 3mg melatonin dose combined with a robust array of synergistic herbs and amino acids (Passionflower, 5-HTP, GABA, Valerian, L-Theanine, Lemon Balm), providing a more holistic and generally safer approach to sleep than an isolated high dose.
92 Performance

Insomnitol

Designs for Health
4.6
(32 ratings)
Features a very comprehensive and transparent blend of clinically relevant ingredients like GABA, Chamomile, 5-HTP, L-Theanine, Valerian, and Passion Flower alongside 3mg melatonin, offering superior multi-pathway support for sleep, contrasting with a singular high dose.
Report alternatives