Product Image

Select Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

4.5
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
(1867 ratings)
Sodium 280 mg
Calcium 280 mg
Milk protein
Protein 23 Gram(s)
Whey Protein
Product Image
Score58
The protein amount is substantial and supports routine dietary protein intake. The listed potassium amount is implausible and requires current-label verification.
How scoring works
Powder
Quantity:31 Ounce(s) • (27 servings)
Goals:

Score 58

The protein amount is substantial and supports routine dietary protein intake. The listed potassium amount is implausible and requires current-label verification.
How scoring works

Also available as

3 options
Amazing Snickerdoodle 31 Gram(s) • 29 Ounce(s) • 27 servings $44.99 ($1.66 per serving) Frosted Chocolate Cupcake 33.5 Gram(s) • 32 Ounce(s) • 27 servings $44.99 ($1.66 per serving) Amazing Cake Pop 31.5 Gram(s) • 30 Ounce(s) • 27 servings $49.99 ($1.85 per serving)
$54.99($2.03 per serving)
iHerb
$ 54.99
Amazon
$ 54.99
Report prices

Analysis

The protein amount is substantial and supports routine dietary protein intake. Calcium and a lean macronutrient profile provide additional utility.

The listed potassium amount is implausible and requires current-label verification. Missing protein sources and inactive ingredients create further uncertainty around quality and allergens.

It fits users only after the potassium figure is confirmed. Anyone unable to verify the label should choose a clearly documented protein powder.

Who is it for
  • It fits users only after the potassium figure is confirmed
  • Anyone unable to verify the label should choose a clearly documented protein powder
Best for
  • Substantial protein amount
  • Provides calcium
  • Lean routine-shake profile

Pros

  • Substantial protein amount
  • Provides calcium
  • Lean routine-shake profile

Cons

  • Potassium amount appears implausible
  • Protein sources are missing
  • Inactive ingredients are not disclosed

Warnings

  • Verify the potassium amount on the current label before use because the supplied figure is implausible.
  • Missing protein-source details prevent reliable allergen screening.
  • Users with kidney impairment or potassium-managing medication should not rely on an unverified potassium figure.

Nutrient quality

56 Moderate impact

The formula supplies meaningful protein but is poorly aligned with the stated goal. A very large mineral or carbohydrate entry further weakens suitability.

Ingredient transparency

69 High impact

Macronutrients and minerals have specific amounts without a hidden blend. Protein-source detail, inactive ingredients, and complete preparation directions remain incomplete.

Customer satisfaction

68 High impact

The aggregate satisfaction signal is moderate and the supplied volume is substantial. No specific experience details are supplied to assess repeated complaints, taste, texture, or purpose-related outcomes.

Value for money

37 Lower impact

The core protein provides some value, but the serving is costly or poorly aligned with the stated use. Weak disclosure or an unbalanced formula further reduces competitiveness.

Report analysis

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per serving
Calories
120 Calorie(s)
Total Fat
1 Gram(s)
Cholesterol
45 mg
Sodium
280 mg
Total Carbohydrates
4 Gram(s)
Protein
23 Gram(s)
Vitamin D
0 mcg
Potassium
23 Gram(s)
Calcium
280 mg
Iron
0 mg
Gluten Free Adults 18–50 Women
Report overview
Sodium · 280 mg OverallScore62
D- Active Ingredient Quality & BioavailabilityB Dose, Safety & Label TransparencyB- Value

The sodium amount can support lighter sweat replacement but sits below the preferred athletic range. Potassium is listed at an implausibly high amount, making that supporting-electrolyte data unreliable, and the sodium source is not disclosed. Protein adds wider nutritional value, while carbohydrate and label uncertainty weaken its hydration fit.

View ingredientView products
Calcium · 280 mg OverallScore49
F Active Ingredient Quality & BioavailabilityB+ Dose, Safety & Label TransparencyF Value

An undisclosed calcium form prevents a meaningful absorption-quality assessment, while the 280 mg amount supports general supplementation but may not cover high needs alone. The elemental amount is clear, and no artificial color, sweetener, or whitening agent appears in the supplied ingredients. A very high serving cost makes it poor value for calcium.

View ingredientView products
Loading alternative details
75 Performance

Micellar Casein Unflavored

California Gold Nutrition SPORT
<p>A more useful protein-and-mineral profile provides 25 g of protein, 650 mg of calcium, and only 35 mg of sodium in 110 calories. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it improves both calcium coverage and sodium control while preserving a full protein serving.</p>
79 Performance

Paleo Thin Egg White Protein 24 g Unflavored

Julian Bakery
<p>A more useful protein-and-mineral profile provides 24 g of protein with no fat or cholesterol and only 1 g of carbohydrate. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it keeps protein comparable while removing the fat and cholesterol listed in the originals, although sodium is higher.</p>
72 Performance

Classic ALLWHEY Cookies & Cream

ALLMAX
<p>A more useful protein-and-mineral profile provides 30 g of protein, 180 mg of calcium, and 230 mg of sodium. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it raises protein meaningfully, with a trade-off of more calories and carbohydrate than most targets.</p>
79 Budget

Casein Protein Elite Series Triple Chocolate

Six Star Pro Nutrition
<p>A lower serving cost still provides 24 g of protein, 580 mg of calcium, and 180 mg of sodium. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it keeps protein close to the original while supplying more calcium than every target in this group.</p>
75 Budget

Organic Protein French Vanilla

Purely Inspired
<p>A lower serving cost still provides 22 g of protein, 150 mg of calcium, and 290 mg of sodium. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it offers a plant-based protein option, though its sodium is higher and its protein is slightly lower than the originals.</p>
81 Budget

Whey Protein Isolate Vanilla

Kaged
<p>A lower serving cost still provides 25 g of protein, 124 mg of calcium, and 160 mg of sodium in 110 calories. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it matches or exceeds the targets’ protein with a leaner calorie profile and moderate sodium.</p>
74 Value

HEXAPRO Chocolate

ALLMAX
<p>A practical value balance combines 25 g of protein, 245 mg of calcium, and 210 mg of sodium with a lower serving cost. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it maintains the same protein level as the HEXAPRO targets and stays close to the PEScience products on calcium.</p>
65 Value

Complete Protein Creamy Vanilla Bean

PlantFusion
<p>A practical value balance combines 21 g of protein, an amino-acid blend, and an enzyme blend with a lower serving cost. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it provides a plant-based formula with added amino acids, but has less protein and considerably more sodium than the originals.</p>
64 Value

Nitro-Tech Milk Chocolate

MuscleTech
<p>A practical value balance combines 30 g of protein, 140 mg of calcium, and 270 mg of sodium with a lower serving cost. Compared with the original’s 23 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 280 mg sodium, it delivers more protein for a competitive serving cost, though calcium is lower and sodium is not especially restrained.</p>
Report alternatives